Magical Make an Offer
Meets our highest standards for performance, design, and integration. Learn moreOpens in new window
Reviews (170)
What merchants think
This is generated by Shopify Magic. It's shown when an app has 100+ reviews and at least a 4.0 overall rating.
This is generated by Shopify Magic. It's shown when an app has 100+ reviews and at least a 4.0 overall rating.
Feedback submitted
Merchants say this app reliably boosts sales and revenue, often by 12–20%+, especially on slow‑moving or high‑ticket items like vintage and consignment goods. They like the easy setup, no‑code workflow, and flexible pricing tools for offers, counteroffers, and pay‑what‑you‑can setups. Many report higher engagement and conversions from “name your price” and exit‑intent offers, and frequently praise fast, hands‑on support and strong value for money.
Refine
-
By rating
"We only charge 2.99% on the offer amount which converts into a fully paid order. Any offers that don’t convert are absolutely FREE! "
Not exactly the 1% advertised
I have been contacted by the company about this review - I suggest you contact shopify to investigate why users are being told they will be charge 2.99% and not the advertised 1%
The app is free to install and only charges up to 1% on completed sales. Offers that don’t convert are always free. If you have questions, reach out anytime and we’ll be glad to help.
Be careful with this company. I installed this app for "FREE TRIAL" then received an email from Shopify as listed below:
You‘ve approved an app with a usage limit of $499.00 USD every 30 days.
App name
Make an Offer
Charge name
Magical Make An Offer - Starter
Charge approval date
August 19, 2025
Approved usage limit
Up to $499.00 every 30 days
By using Make an Offer, you have agreed to pay-per-use charges following these terms:
1% Transaction Fees on Completed Offers
These pay-per-use charges will not go over a maximum amount of $499.00 per month.
The app is free to install and charges up to 1% on completed sales. The cap shown at install is just a Shopify pre-approval and only applies at very high sales volumes. In this case, the customer was not charged.
So far so okay. We cannot answer some offers. Connection to the website is "not safe". Could be a nice app with improvements
This one's from a while back. The app has come a long way since 2019 and these issues have been sorted for a while now.
Preise sind unverschämt teuer, suchen nach einer Alternative!
We hear ya. We've since restructured our pricing to be clearer and more competitive. Check out the listing for current details.
Completely MISLEADING and dishonest. It's FREE to install then they charge 2%!!!!!! Ridiculous APP. They charge more then a BANK!!!! Be honest with your clients...
A lot has changed since 2019. Our pricing has been completely restructured since then. Check out the listing for the latest details.
