Magical Make an Offer

Magical Make an Offer

Reviews (170)

Overall rating
4.7
Counts per rating level
  • 86% of ratings are 5 stars
  • 9% of ratings are 4 stars
  • 0% of ratings are 3 stars
  • 2% of ratings are 2 stars
  • 3% of ratings are 1 stars
What merchants think

Feedback submitted

Merchants say this app reliably boosts sales and revenue, often by 12–20%+, especially on slow‑moving or high‑ticket items like vintage and consignment goods. They like the easy setup, no‑code workflow, and flexible pricing tools for offers, counteroffers, and pay‑what‑you‑can setups. Many report higher engagement and conversions from “name your price” and exit‑intent offers, and frequently praise fast, hands‑on support and strong value for money.

July 11, 2024

The app developers went above and beyond helping me to set up this app when I had difficulty with understanding how to navigate the set up. I'm new to Shopify so it's likely an easy app that's somewhat difficult because of my lack of experience with website development.

Possible suggested change for app developer: I don't like that the customer gets an email from "Magical Make an Offer" instead of from me. I'm using this app for donations to be given and donors could think it's a spam email being sent to them. It would also be nice if there was a way for me to send the customer a customized email after they've completed the purchase.

Artsy Paint
United States
16 days using the app
January 25, 2016

Very useful app. Recently start using it. Will need some additional features though such as linking the offer more directly with all the product info. But for the price, I cannot complain.

Lcdtvboards
United States
20 days using the app
Edited May 29, 2018

Very helpful app. Announcing a sale, in this case a Moving Sale, really helped kick up interest - and the Make an Offer sale resulted in much greater sales than a year-end sale. I sell skis, and they come in numerous lengths. The app allowed individuals to make purchases without specifying length, which created extra work to resolve.

2018/5/29: The ability to limit the pop up to certain items has proven very useful. I enable the pop up on clearance items, which helps move them, and don't enable it on current items, which preserves pricing and makes my retailers happy.

Hagan Ski Mountaineering
United States
8 months using the app
July 17, 2017

This app was instrumental in getting some of our products moving. We like the interface and implementation within our Shopify account. Of course, it does lend itself to some lowball offers that come in, but it gives some interesting data on what people are willing to pay for certain items.

Ebikemarketplace Com
United States
About 2 months using the app
March 22, 2018

Amazing customer service :) Happy with the results. Please go for it!

Dulcinaantiques Com
United States
About 15 hours using the app
Edited December 30, 2018

Overall I am happy with this app. However I would be even more happy to read the SKU when I am receiving the offer on an item.

QualityDiam
Belgium
10 months using the app
December 30, 2018

Great product wish there was better notification but otherwise love the opportunity it gives us to offer our customers

Inferno Sports and Athletics
United States
Over 1 year using the app
April 18, 2019

Really useful app that has produced revenue for our store. Customers love having the ability to negotiate and this gives them an easy way to do it.

MusicGoldmine.com
United States
5 months using the app
Edited April 16, 2020

App is working very good for us, just note that sometimes it won't send SMS to you for few days but it will work again as usual .. the 2% fees is little high specially when an item is not a low price item but overall it is a very good app.

Rental HQ
United States
4 months using the app
Magical Apps replied May 6, 2020

Thankyou so much for your feedback - we are deep diving the SMS issue as we speak and will make sure its working reliably. We really appreciate you bringing this to our attention, i love it!

May 3, 2020

I love the app. Without a doubt it has increased sales. Because I own a brick and mortar resale clothing store, making an offer is a perfect way to be more interactive with my online shoppers. Customizing the responses was important for me and seems to work perfectly with the automated messages. The only reason why I did not give it all stars is because the text alert does not work at all. I’m constantly logging on to the app and refreshing it to see if there are new offers throughout the day. I really do wish the text portion worked. Otherwise, lots of offers received, lots of counters and lots of accepted!

Wicked Thrift & PopRock Vintage
United States
About 1 month using the app
Magical Apps replied May 6, 2020

Thankyou thankyou! love the feedback. We are so sorry about the text issue - we are deep diving that issue right now and will have a solve for you soon. Thanks for your patience and thank you so much for bringing it to our attention.