Reviews (177)

Overall rating
4.9
Counts per rating level
  • 99% of ratings are 5 stars
  • 1% of ratings are 4 stars
  • 0% of ratings are 3 stars
  • 0% of ratings are 2 stars
  • 1% of ratings are 1 stars
What merchants think

Feedback submitted

Merchants say this direct mail platform delivers strong ROI and often becomes a top channel, boosting repeat purchases and LTV. It’s used for winbacks, post‑purchase flows, birthdays, reactivation, and acquisition/prospecting. They like the intuitive interface, real-time reporting, and deep integrations for granular targeting. Many highlight fast, on-brand creative, done‑for‑you strategy and execution, and proactive, “white‑glove” support that feels like an extension of their team.

August 21, 2026

PostPilot has been a fantastic partner for our team. Taylor Casalanguida consistently brings thoughtful optimization recommendations, fresh testing ideas, and a proactive approach that helps us continuously improve performance. Her responsiveness, strategic thinking, and commitment to our success make PostPilot a valuable extension of our team. Highly recommend both the platform and the people behind it.

Liquid I.V.
United States
Over 2 years using the app
August 20, 2026

We’ve had a great experience using PostPilot. The platform has been a valuable addition to our marketing strategy, helping us connect with customers in a unique and effective way. It’s easy to work with, and we’ve especially appreciated having such a great support team behind us. Mikaela and team are responsive, helpful, and always willing to jump in when we have questions or need guidance. Overall, PostPilot has been a great partner for our team, and we’d definitely recommend their services!

Portland Leather
United States
Over 3 years using the app
August 20, 2026

We've had tremendous success with PostPilot and have been impressed with both the platform and team behind it. We've seen strong, measurable results across campaigns - including a recent winback campaign that generated more that $408K in revenue at a 10x ROAS.

What really sets PostPilot apart is their partnership - the entire team is incredibly responsive, proactive and strategic. They actively work with us to identify opportunities, test new approaches and improve performance making them a valuable part of our customer acquisition and retention strategy. Highly recommend for brands looking for a DM partner that combines strong performance, smart strategy and exceptional support!

Swanson Vitamins
United States
5 months using the app
Edited August 17, 2026

Sketchy cancellation practices... BEWARE. I've signed up for them twice along the years for a brief period that I need to send postcards. Both times when I go to cancel my subscription that you're unable to cancel on your own, and instead send an email to their support email (which they never respond to unless you loop in an account manager) they request that I either hop on a call or fill out a form, which 4 emails deep they've yet to provide said form. They intentionally make it hard to cancel even after asking multiple times. Their cancellation practices are unnecessarily obstructive and inconsistent with their own marketing. “You can easily change plans or cancel at any time.”

Edit: The co-CEO read this review and reached out to offer some free postcards. After I took him up on his offer to get some compensation for them wasting my time, he followed up asking me to "update" this review. This might be one of the reasons this is the only one star review. Take the reviews on this page with caution.

Proud Patriots
United States
About 6 years using the app
September 8, 2026

PostPilot is an incredible partner. The team provides true white-glove service, is incredibly responsive, and makes every step of the process feel seamless. Nicole and the team are a pleasure to work with, and I always feel supported. Highly recommend!

Alpyn Beauty
United States
Over 2 years using the app
September 2, 2026

This app has changed out business in terms of retention. The staff, the user ability all of it. 10/10.

Axe & Sledge Supplements
United States
10 months using the app
August 25, 2026

We love working with PostPilot and especially Mikaela. Such strategic and thoughtful partners who push our business forward.

Fresh Clean Threads
United States
About 3 years using the app
August 20, 2026

PostPilot has been a great partner to our brand! Mikaela S. and her team are deeply rigorous and have helped us scale our direct mail campaigns over the last 12 months!

Skylight
United States
About 2 years using the app
August 20, 2026

PostPilot has been an amazing direct mail partner and best in class. Their incrementality tracking is the gold standard. It makes decision-making easy. Taylor is the best CSM!

HexClad Cookware
United States
Over 4 years using the app
September 1, 2026

We love working with Horacio from PostPilot.

HULKEN®
United States
7 months using the app