Magical Make an Offer

Magical Make an Offer

Reviews (170)

Overall rating
4.7
Counts per rating level
  • 86% of ratings are 5 stars
  • 9% of ratings are 4 stars
  • 0% of ratings are 3 stars
  • 2% of ratings are 2 stars
  • 3% of ratings are 1 stars
What merchants think

Feedback submitted

Merchants say this app reliably boosts sales and revenue, often by 12–20%+, especially on slow‑moving or high‑ticket items like vintage and consignment goods. They like the easy setup, no‑code workflow, and flexible pricing tools for offers, counteroffers, and pay‑what‑you‑can setups. Many report higher engagement and conversions from “name your price” and exit‑intent offers, and frequently praise fast, hands‑on support and strong value for money.

Edited April 1, 2020

Surprisingly the best app we ever found. Lots of leads and sales can be acquired through Make An Offer. Still going strong 2 years later!!

JDM Engine Zone
United States
Over 2 years using the app
April 13, 2017

It is great, I increased my sales with this plugin. Thank you. Just one recommendation: the pop-up should not appear in products with $0.00, it is very confusing for my customers.

Vj Galaxy
Spain
16 days using the app
July 17, 2017

This app was instrumental in getting some of our products moving. We like the interface and implementation within our Shopify account. Of course, it does lend itself to some lowball offers that come in, but it gives some interesting data on what people are willing to pay for certain items.

Ebikemarketplace Com
United States
About 2 months using the app
October 29, 2018

A great app to drive communication with customers. Probably most valuable for high price items where you have enough margin to offer discounts. This gives some price control back to the customer and in our experience creates genuine and reasonable offers in the most part. So all in all a great addition to our site.

NZ Pacific
New Zealand
About 1 year using the app
May 3, 2020

I love the app. Without a doubt it has increased sales. Because I own a brick and mortar resale clothing store, making an offer is a perfect way to be more interactive with my online shoppers. Customizing the responses was important for me and seems to work perfectly with the automated messages. The only reason why I did not give it all stars is because the text alert does not work at all. I’m constantly logging on to the app and refreshing it to see if there are new offers throughout the day. I really do wish the text portion worked. Otherwise, lots of offers received, lots of counters and lots of accepted!

Wicked Thrift & PopRock Vintage
United States
About 1 month using the app
Magical Apps replied May 6, 2020

Thankyou thankyou! love the feedback. We are so sorry about the text issue - we are deep diving that issue right now and will have a solve for you soon. Thanks for your patience and thank you so much for bringing it to our attention.

November 7, 2015

This is an amazing ap and it's been very beneficial for us. Instead of guessing how low we need to go on price, we price at what we think is market and use this ap to get offers from prospects at the price they'd like to buy our product. Who doesn't want to get a deal? We have worked with the developers to test their enhancements - now when someone makes an offer I get an immediate summary of their offer with email address so I can respond. If the offer works for me, I enter the order in shopify, apply the requested discount, and send them an invoice with a note from me thanking them for the offer. So far, 80 percent of the offers I have invoiced have been purchased. This really changes the online sales game. Oh by the way, these guys have been great to work with!

Mrmuffinstrains
United States
24 days using the app
July 18, 2016

I installed this about 2 weeks ago. After a few days, I got two offers. It was quiet for a while and then in recent days I got 2 more offers. Though I still see some people come and check it out and leave, so far, of those who have made an offer, when I counter back with something more reasonable, they seem to take it. I don't know in the long term how it affects my bottom line, but when just starting out, it's a great way to get sales in and a great way to not publicize really large discount prices. I decided to move my prices up because it didn't seem to affect sales either way but Make an Offer is a way to offer discounts to customers who wouldn't buy even at my low prices. it's your own decision if that is a smart move but it has helped to sell, bring in some $, and prevent me from constantly offering discounts. Sometimes offering discount coupons and publicizing them can also hurt your brand.

Multiwear
United States
21 days using the app
May 25, 2017

I've installed a lot of apps in my Shopify shop. This is by far the most user friendly, convenient and SIMPLE app I've seen! The setup page is intuitive, and you don't need to be a programmer to customize the best offer app (a huge plus for busy shop owners).

I had this app up and running in my shop in LESS than a minute! Once it was up, I tested it and it worked like a dream! I can't say enough good things about a Shopify add-on that didn't make me tear my hair out getting it set up. I'm so used to things being difficult that the level of simplicity blew me away. Thank you so much for considering the non-tech savvy!

"Make an Offer" installed like a dream and didn't mess with any of my formats - it does what it says it does! All you have to do is click some buttons, maybe slide a color slider to tweak your color scheme, and type a little text to customize the look. That's IT! It comes with an inbox so you can handle your offers. An email is also sent to your registered email so that you know an offer has arrived.

Accepting, countering and declining offers is as easy as a push of a button. Click - click - DONE!

In addition to Make an Offer being so user-friendly, the developers have an excellent support network. My inquiries were always answered quickly, professionally, and in a friendly manner. They stand by their product - so much so that you can make them offers on the app price itself!

In my collectibles based market, most products do not have a set price. Being able to barter with customers is ESSENTIAL. Even if you aren't in a market where bartering is commonplace, give it a shot. Giving your customers the option to shave off even $1.00 is attractive, interactive, and fun. It gives you a unique chance to have conversations with your visitors and learn more about their needs.

Thanks so much for this app - and thanks for your excellent support!

Cherdens Doujinshi Shop
United States
31 minutes using the app
Edited October 12, 2018

Thank you very much for this incredible app! Thanks to your app our conversion rate went up significantly

BenzDiamonds
United States
6 months using the app
September 25, 2019

Good app. I used it for over 6 months now and it works very well, helpful for business. It was really easy to set up.

DSF Antique Jewelry
United States
6 months using the app