Magical Make an Offer

Magical Make an Offer

Reviews (170)

Overall rating
4.7
Counts per rating level
  • 86% of ratings are 5 stars
  • 9% of ratings are 4 stars
  • 0% of ratings are 3 stars
  • 2% of ratings are 2 stars
  • 3% of ratings are 1 stars
What merchants think

Feedback submitted

Merchants say this app reliably boosts sales and revenue, often by 12–20%+, especially on slow‑moving or high‑ticket items like vintage and consignment goods. They like the easy setup, no‑code workflow, and flexible pricing tools for offers, counteroffers, and pay‑what‑you‑can setups. Many report higher engagement and conversions from “name your price” and exit‑intent offers, and frequently praise fast, hands‑on support and strong value for money.

May 1, 2019

The app has increased my sales in items which otherwise were not so popular. I had a problem with the synchronization to my own data base using Shopify Webhooks, and the Make an Offer technical support updated the app so that Make an Offer now support the passing of custom properties through the Shopping Cart. It's indeed a prime quality technical support, and ready to help.
Direct contact with the technical people and fast answers when you have a doubt.
100% recommended.

Jurassic Dreams
Spain
About 2 months using the app
August 27, 2022

We installed the app for a shmita offering so customer can set the prices themselves. This really encouraged customers to buy more than they normally would and more people were interested in the product than had there been a list price. There is still some work to be done to make it more customisable - we have a black background and certain parts of the offer window are not yet customisable, so stayed white which is for an up market brand not ideal. So we are looking forward to the next version. Blessings

Love To Worship
United Kingdom
5 months using the app
Magical Apps replied September 8, 2022

Thank you very much for the kind review, really happy we could help! We are always looking to improve Make an Offer so we are thankful for your suggestions as well!

Edited May 29, 2018

Very helpful app. Announcing a sale, in this case a Moving Sale, really helped kick up interest - and the Make an Offer sale resulted in much greater sales than a year-end sale. I sell skis, and they come in numerous lengths. The app allowed individuals to make purchases without specifying length, which created extra work to resolve.

2018/5/29: The ability to limit the pop up to certain items has proven very useful. I enable the pop up on clearance items, which helps move them, and don't enable it on current items, which preserves pricing and makes my retailers happy.

Hagan Ski Mountaineering
United States
8 months using the app
March 30, 2022

This app has been a game changer for our business. It's opened up so many conversations, increased our sales and has even helped us grow our email list. Out of all the Shopify apps we currently use, this is by far our favorite. If you sell low ticket products with small margins then this probably wouldn't be a great app for you but if you sell higher end products with some wiggle room to wheel and deal, this app is ideal for your business. Remember that when someone makes an offer, even if you deny it, it still becomes a win because you now have insight into a customer that's been looking at your products.

Artist Replete
United States
About 2 years using the app
Magical Apps replied March 30, 2022

Thank you for the review and the kind words, it means a lot to our team! Do not hesitate to reach out in the future if we can be of any help for anything!

June 12, 2018

This app is pretty great and for us, it has generated in the first month (trial month) over $5k additional revenue.

I don't think of it as a cheap app, I think of it as an app that allows you to connect with customers in a way you usually can't. By opening up the door to hearing from customers their issues with price, you give yourself a chance to have a dialog with the customer.

I also love how it has filters so for some products it can accept automatically, and others it counters.

Their support team was amazing, and they even added additional functionality for me personally, which was a life saver. To Ivan specifically, I'm thrilled you did what you did, and so quickly too!

Elevatione
United Kingdom
About 1 month using the app
Edited May 29, 2018

Outstanding service and communication from developer. There are some email glitches that we are working on. This is a valuable tool that my website greatly needed. I have had several sales as a result of this app. I am still trying it out, but I am leaning towards keeping it. It's not yet automated so you'll have to create a system for processing the offers. But the offers do come in. I am seeing some degree of customers not following through once the offer is accepted. I am working on a system for that. I absolutely recommend this app. I think that it is going to grow into a phenomenal tool that I will always want to have. Thank you Make an Offer! UPDATE: I left this app for a while because I needed automation. When they became automated they actually cared enough about my business to contact me several times to come back. I did not want to disturb my website, but this weekend I got a new theme and came back to MAO. I am so glad that I did. I was using Pricewaiter and I can tell you that THIS is the better offer app. If you are trying to decide, take it from me. Make an Offer is the one to chose. Better product and customer service that lets you know that this company cares about their customers. If I could give it 10 stars, I would!!

Yourgreatfinds
United States
About 1 year using the app
November 19, 2018

Great app to catch the customers and to encourage them to start interaction. Resulting sales well :)

Kello ja Kulta Widemark
Finland
About 2 months using the app
June 27, 2018

Useful app that does what it says. You can trust Ivan and their support team will help with any question you may have.

Pro Line Racing
United States
About 1 year using the app
Edited April 11, 2019

So far so okay. We cannot answer some offers. Connection to the website is "not safe". Could be a nice app with improvements

JCMaster Beauty
Germany
About 1 month using the app
Magical Apps replied April 14, 2026

This one's from a while back. The app has come a long way since 2019 and these issues have been sorted for a while now.

Edited December 30, 2018

Overall I am happy with this app. However I would be even more happy to read the SKU when I am receiving the offer on an item.

QualityDiam
Belgium
10 months using the app